The Café at Middlebury Consignment

The Café at Middlebury Consignment is truly a hidden gem of a restaurant tucked inside a huge building filled with furniture & home accessories.

The Café is quaint and cozy, providing comfortable seating for around 60 people. There are also a few coveted seats at the over-sized granite preparation bar in the warm kitchen where lunchtime diners can watch the chefs at work and later attend cooking classes that are held at night.

Executive chefs Mike Trudeau and Mary Kravec are proud to cook and teach in the beautifully appointed kitchen and adjoining dining room. The outdoor patio by the waterfall and beautiful gardens is the perfect spot to enjoy a relaxing lunch, or host an event.

Once you visit The Café at Middlebury Consignment, you will be back to explore the ever-changing menu and classes.

Open for Lunch 11:30 a.m. to 3 p.m. | 7 Days

Now serving Dinner 5 p.m. to 9:30 p.m. every Thursday, Friday and Saturday

Live Entertainment begins at 7 p.m. and the Café is open until 11 p.m.
Reservations Recommended | (203) 528-0130

We’re opening for dinner! Enjoy a menu featuring seasonal vegetables, new flatbreads and rich entrees that go perfectly with autumnal wines and cocktails. We’ll have live music Thursday through Sunday and a perfect table on the patio waiting for you.


Our famous french onion soup

Traditional style onion soup with caramelized onions in a beef broth with croutons and melted cheese.
Served with a savory biscotti. Pairs with Milbrant Vineyards Riesling


Seasonal Soup

Ask your server for today’s selection. Served with a savory biscotti.



The Whittemore Bistro Salad

Mixed greens with goat cheese, sweet & spicy pecans and cranberries tossed with our white balsamic vinaigrette.
Pairs with Milbrandt Traditions Riesling

*add one: prosciutto, roast beef, turkey, black forest ham, or sundried tomato tuna salad – add $4.25


Middlebury Chicken Salad

Our own chicken salad made with diced chicken, dried cranberries, granny smith apples, grapes, celery, parsley, sour cream & mayo served over mixed greens and sweet & spicy pecans.
Pairs with Milbrandt Traditions Riesling


Mandarin Beet Salad

Roasted beets, mandarin oranges, gorgonzola, red onion, sliced fennel, sweet & savory pecans, over mixed greens tossed with our apricot ginger vinaigrette.
Pairs with Massimo Sauvignon Blanc


Southwestern Chicken Caesar Salad

Spiced chicken breast over romaine; tossed in our avocado chipotle creamy Caesar dressing, topped with black bean-corn-roasted red pepper salad, tortilla strips and cheddar.
Pairs with Laetitia Pinot Noir


Salad Dressings
White Balsamic Vinaigrette – Apricot Ginger Vinaigrette – Avocado Chipotle Ceasar Dressing

Quiche & Savory Pies

Puff Pastry Quiche

A savory egg custard in puff pastry. Ask your server for today’s offerings.


Savory Pie

A savory filling du jour enclosed in puff pastry. Ask your server for today’s offerings.


Quiche & Savory Pies served with a Side Salad.


Prosciutto, Fig & Goat Cheese Baguette

Prosciutto, fig preserves, goat cheese, red onion & arugula on a baguette.
Pairs with: Cantina Zaccagnini


Garlic-Peppercon Roast Beef Baguette

Our own garlic-peppercorn roast beef with house made horseradish-boursin cheese, arugula, and fried onions on a baguette, drizzled with a balsamic reduction.
Pairs with Annabella Cabernet


Rosemary Lemon-Pepper Roast Turkey

Rosemary lemon-pepper roast turkey with cranberry mayo, cheddar, and fried sage on multigrain bread.
Pairs with Irony Chardonnay


Middlebury Chicken Salad Croissant

Our own chicken salad with diced chicken, dried cranberries, Granny Smith apples, grapes, celery, parsley, sour cream & mayo on a croissant with lettuce.
Pairs with Danzante Pinot Grigio


French Ham Croissant

Black Forest ham with Granny Smith apple, brie, and spinach with a Béarnaise mustard on a croissant.
Pairs with Irony Chardonnay


The Veggie Panini

Artichoke hearts, pesto, roasted pepper, breaded eggplant, Swiss and spinach on Italian panini bread.
Pairs with Laetitia Pinot Noir


Cali Tuna Sandwich

White Albacore tuna with a sundried tomato mayo spread, applewood bacon, avocado and fresh mozzarella on toasted marbled rye.
Pairs with: Laetitia Pinot Noir


All sandwiches served with a side salad.



Middlebury Special Blend Coffee


Cappuccino / Latte


Espresso /Americano


Hot Chocolate with Whipped Cream
Add flavor shot to any beverage



Unsweetened House Brewed Iced Tea


Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Ginger Ale, Cranberry Juice, Seltzer, Tonic


Orange Juice



CT’s Own Harney & Sons Tea Sachets
Ask your server for tea selections.


*Please Note
$3.00 sharing charge for entrees
20% gratuity added to parties of 6 or more.

For a selection of finer wines please ask for our reserve cellar list.

* Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have a medical condition.


Our Onion Soup

Toasted Bread Gruyere


Chef’s Daily Soup


Roasted Brussel Sprouts

Pancetta, Local Apple, Asiago, Fermented Black Garlic Aioli


Chilled Shrimp Cocktail

4 Jumbo Chilled Shrimp Cocktail, Herb Salad, Lemon-Caper Aioli, Classic Horseradish Cocktail Sauce


Shrimp Scampi Toast

Colossal Shrimp, Shaved Garlic, Baby Heirloom Tomatoes, Chardonnay, Lemon, Butter, Grilled Baguette


Artisanal Cheese Plate

4 Artisan cheeses, sliced baguette, truffle honey, grapes, chutney dried fruits and spiced pecans


Artisanal Antipasti

Salumi, cured meats, marinated wild mushrooms, long stem artichokes, grana padano, fire roasted peppers & burrata


Burrata & Parma Prosciutto

Citrus salad, shaved fennel, toasted pistachio, pea shoot & crostini


Pan Seared Sea Scallops

Roasted butternut squash, wild mushrooms & a pomegranate-balsamic reduction



Tuscan White Bean: Caramelized Onions, Asparagus, Rosemary, Provolone, Oven Roasted Tomatoes, Wild Mushrooms, Asiago Cheese


Spicy Fennel Sausage:  Fire Roasted Peppers, Smoked Fresh Mozzarella, Oregano, Pomodoro Sauce


Fig & Roasted Garlic:  Roasted butternut squash, moody blue cheese, fried sage, baby arrugula & truffle oil



Chicken Caesar Salad

Lemon herb chicken, romaine, radicchio, black pepper croutons, Dean’s creamy garlic dressing, parmesan crisps, white anchovies


Chicken, Shaved Brussel & Kale Sprout Salad

Candied pecans, roasted butternut squash, pickled cauliflower, goat cheese, pancetta, sun dried cranberries, pickled onions & white balsamic viniagrette



Grilled Cubano

Pulled pork, black forest ham, swiss, pickles, dijon mustard, celery fennel salad


Lemon Pepper - Rosemary Turkey Breast Club

Applewood smoked bacon, baby lettuce, heirloom tomatoes, mustard bernaise on multi grain toast


Roasted Prime Rib Baguette

Caramelized onions, wild mushrooms, bell peppers, garlic spread and smoked cheddar



Crispy Breast of Chicken

Eggplant, roasted portabella mushooms & tomatoes, spinach goat cheese,
rigatoni pomodoro


Mezzi Rogatino ala Vodka

Italian sausage, roasted red peppers, pomodoro sauce, cream, parmigiana


Sfoglini Semolina Trumpet Pasta

Extra virgin olive oil, roasted garlic, shrimp, baby tomatoes, asparagus, artichoke heart


Cavatelli Pasta

Hazelnuts, broccolli rabe, sun dried tomatoes, cannellini beans


Pesto Crusted Salmon

Fennel-wild mushroom risotto, red wine tomato butter sauce


Pan Seared Sea Scallops

Butternut squash puree, apple-quinoa pilaf, pomegranate reduction, baby vegetable


Orange - Miso Glazed Sea Bass

Roasted fingerling potatoes, baby beets, sesame ginger asparagus


Feta-Dijon Crusted Rack of Lamb

Roasted garlic whipped potatoes, sautéed haricot vert, fall fruit chutney & rosemary jus


Pan Roasted Filet Mignon

Balsamic roasted cipollini onions, port wine-rosemary jus, broccoli rabe and roasted garlic whipped potatoes